Skip to Main Content

Ecology, Environmental Science and Botany: What are Peer Reviewed, Academic and Scholarly Articles?

What does Scholarly, Peer Reviewed, or Academic mean?

When conducting research, professors may use many of the terms below interchangeably when asking you to find articles for your assignments.

A Peer-Reviewed, Scholarly, or Academic Journal is a publication that is published periodically (weekly, monthly, annually, etc.) and contains original research by scholars, professors, or experts.

They differ from magazines and newspapers in a variety of ways:

Popular Articles

Scholarly Articles

Written by:

Journalist or layperson. Sometimes written anonymously.

Covered by an expert in the field (scientist, researcher, professor, etc.). The author is identified.

Notes

Few or no references or notes

Includes notes and/or a bibliography

Publisher

A corporation

An academic institution, research organization, or professional association

Writing Style

Written for the average reader

Written for experts and scholars

Editing

Reviewed by magazine employees

Editorial board of outside scholars reviews the article before it gets published

Contents

Current events and general interest

Research topics

Frequency

Usually weekly or monthly

Usually quarterly, monthly, or annually

Layout

*Brief articles

*Many advertisements

*Many illustrations in color

*Many photographs

*Few charts, graphs, tables, and  diagrams

*Articles aren't summarized

*Long articles

*Few advertisements, if any

*Most illustrations in black and white

*Minimal photographs

*Many charts, graphs, tables, and diagrams

*Articles often summarized; this summary is called an ABSTRACT

Where to buy

An individual issue may be purchased at a bookstore or supermarket at a nominal cost

Requires a subscription or membership in a professional association. Subscriptions can be expensive, often hundreds of dollars.

Understand & Identify Peer-Reviewed Articles in 5 Minutes